The Spitfire Grill was a hit with me when it came out almost 30 years ago. It made a big impression on me. I remembered almost all the plot twists watching it again all these years later. There will be spoilers ahead.
The Spitfire Grill was a heartwarming, tearjerker kind of movie. You were rooting for the characters and wanted them to succeed. It used so many tropes to tell the story. I didn’t notice them back in 1996, but they bothered me this time through.
Hannah (Ellen Burstyn) lived in Gilead, Maine. She ran a small cafe called The Spitfire Grill. Into her life walked ex-con Percy (Alison Elliott), who just got out of a Maine prison where she’d worked answering phones for the Maine tourist bureau. She fell in love with Maine in the process.
Percy was sent to Gilead with instructions to see Sheriff Walsh (Gailard Sartain) about a job. He convinced Hannah to put Percy to work. Hannah’s nephew Nahum (Will Patton) was very suspicious of the girl just out of prison. He’d been trying to sell the grill for Hannah for almost 10 years.
Hannah conveniently broke her leg about then, and Percy had to take over running the grill. She was a terrible cook.
Nahum’s wife Shelby (Marcia Gay Harden) stepped up and starting doing the cooking. She taught Percy as she went along. She was the one who learned all of Percy’s backstory.
When Percy heard that Hannah couldn’t find a buyer for the grill, she told Shelby about an essay contest she learned about while in prison. People send in $100 as an entry fee along with an essay about why they wanted to own the grill. The winner of the essay contest gets the grill and Hannah gets all the entry fees.
There was a subplot about a mysterious man that Hannah gave canned food to at night. Percy was very curious about him and started following him and trying to engage him in conversation.
Nahum’s interest in the money Hannah was collecting from all the essay letters was another subplot.
The worst trope of all was that (spoiler) Percy dies. Her sacrifice to save someone brings the town together to celebrate the new owner of the grill, brings the mystery man down out of the hills, and leaves the audience in tears.
I’d forgotten the manipulation of killing off Percy from my first watch. Didn’t like it so I blanked it out. She was such a spunky spitfire herself, I really liked her character. Her mere presence was enough to change the town, she didn’t need to die. Sadly, even more recently written material often uses the idea of killing off a favorite character.
Even with that awful outcome for Percy, I enjoyed watching this movie again. I responded as intended to all the emotional twists and felt moved when it was over. Seeing favorite actors like Ellen Burstyn and Marcia Gay Harden as much younger women was a fun reminder of all the years I’ve enjoyed these two brilliant actors.
The film is available on Tubi, Plex, and Roku Channel. Let me know if you watch it again, and what you thought of it the second time around.
Discover more from Old Ain't Dead
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Ellen Burstyn has always been a favorite. Until I saw this blog title, I’d forgotten about The Spitfire Grill. Curious, and because I couldn’t recall the plot, story or characters, I was eager to watch this again. As I watched, sadly, it became clear why I’d forgotten the movie:
* The acting. An unconvincing performance by Allison Elliot. Marcia Gay Harden, who I’ve loved in everything else I’ve seen her in, over-acted. Burstyn was okay. Surprisingly, the most believable performance was given by an actor whose character had no real bearing on the plot, Kieran Mulroney as Joe.
* Tropes. Devolved too easily into cliches (the mysterious recluse, incestuous stepfather, inexplicably cruel husband).
* Chacterizations. The Eli character wasn’t developed well enough to build the story upon. Motives for his reclusiveness are not clear. We are given only a thin reference to war trauma as a possible explanation. His reclusiveness includes alienation from his mother, but why? Issues in that relationship not at all touched upon. Eli is a clear reminder of Boo Radley, which unavoidably draws comparisons. Where Boo is mysterious, Eli is just vague. Boo takes root in imagination and inspires deep empathy. Eli never does. He never rises above stereotype. All of which weakens the story.
* Plot hole. A bag has $250,000 in it. Let’s say the money is all in $20 bills. According to a google search, that bag would weigh 27.9 pounds, even more if it contained a mixture of smaller bills (there would be far more of them). Percy handles this heavy bag without in any way noticing its weight, or noticing that there’s anything at all inside of it. Her unawareness is understandable, of course, given that we could see with our own eyes that there was nothing in the bag! Yet the whole plot turns on this implausible event.
* Story climax. In a phrase, it was rushed and absurd. The director’s inattention to detail was frustrating; for example, no effort to perform CPR, lack of bruising on a face that surely would have been bashed against the rocks. Sounds like nitpicking, I know. But if I’m expected to accept nonsense, then the least director should do is pay attention to obvious cetails.
After nearly 30 years, I cannot say for certain why The Spitfire Grill made its way onto my forgotten list. Certainly, I didn’t have the benefit of Google back then, LOL. But these are today’s clear reasons. Thankfully, I have Ellen Burstyn gems like “Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore” and “Resurrection” to return to again and again!
Thanks for the comment. I appreciate you reading the review.